Surely you've seen bad papers published in good journals before this. Rather Bogdanov thesis reports suing Riazuelo for defamationBogdanov Bogdanov thesis reports a criminal complaint of copyright droit d'auteur violation against him in May Elsewhere, an added word demonstrated, according to Majid, that "Bogdanov does not understand his own draft results.
Some of the papers of the Bogdanoff brothers are really painful and clearly silly He replied to the mysterious Yang; Yang emailed back, again from France So, I was able to contact Hong Kong University and check that there was no International Institute of Mathematical Physics at this university, and no Bogdanov thesis reports Yang" in their physics department.
This makes a total of 15 reports which is quite unusual in itself since normally a thesis only requires 2 reports. But inon the 22nd of October many of us began hearing rumors that two brothers managed to publish at least five meaningless papers in physics journals as a hoax - and even got Ph.
Alas, I was completely mistaken. You can read some of the subsequent dialog on my websiteand more on sci. Thuan had copied their own earlier work, so they never paid him any money. Majid said that the French version of his report on Grichka's thesis was "an unauthorized translation partially invented by the Bogdanovs.
The scandal it caused in French academia was dealt with by a committee of professors who wrote a long report Later, the editor-in-chief of the journal issued a slightly different statement on behalf of the Institute of Physicswhich owns the journal, in which he insisted on the fact that their usual peer-review procedures had been followed, but no longer commented on the value of the paper.
He is indeed using actual physics jargon - but I assure you, it makes no sense. But in Januaryfour members of the French Academie des Sciences Yves Coppens, Jean Dorst, Andre Lichnerowicz, Etienne Wolf issued an affidavit, confirmed by Jacques Friedel, then President of the Academy, giving among others a non exhaustive list of 9 quotations, 5 of them appearing in "La melodie secrete", which come from texts by Guitton or the twins prior to the latter fromand early What theory should then prevail at this scale.
I do not think that any of the above is valid reasoning.
The French mainstream media, in both the press and on the Internet, covered the renewed controversy to some extent; media outlets that have reported upon it include Europe 1 Acrimed,  and Ciel et Espace. After a legal battle in France, Thuan and the Bogdanovs settled out of court, and the Bogdanovs later denied all wrongdoing.
I find it unlikely that these things will work but it is probably more likely than loop quantum gravity and other discrete approaches whose lethal problems have already been identified in detail". In particular the sentences " Robert Coquereaux, from the International Centre for Mathematical Meetings in Marseille, has said that the brothers' work is certainly no better or worse than that of some established theoretical physicists.
After a legal battle in France, Thuan and the Bogdanovs settled out of court, and the Bogdanovs later denied all wrongdoing. In Augustthey presented a minute special cosmology program in which they introduced their theory among other cosmological scenarios.
The journal's Editorial Board became aware of this situation already in April If this was the essence of the statement, Baez noted, it cannot be very useful in "explaining the origin of inertia ".
This has been the basis of concerns raised about the efficacy of the peer-review system that the scientific community and academia use to determine the merit of submitted manuscripts for publication; one concern is that over-worked and unpaid referees may not be able to thoroughly judge the value of a paper in the little time they can afford to spend on it.
They have the right to have their work recognized with a diploma, which is nothing much these days. Sokal's original aim had been to test the effects of the intellectual trend he called, "for want of a better term, postmodernism ".
Urs Schreiber, a postdoctoral researcher at the University of Hamburgnoted that the mention of the Foucault pendulum was at odds with the papers' general tone, since they generally relied upon more "modern terminology".
That would be a good thing to do. The Bogdanovs have claimed several times that the "domain name 'th-phys. Some physicists have also treated this as evidence of the fallibility inherent within the peer review system.
The Chinese Journal of Physics, Nuovo Cimento and Annals of Physics papers are essentially identical except for their titles and abstracts; typographical errors are also repeated across these versions. There must be two sides to the controversy, and the reporter's job is to elicit quotes from both parties and present them side-by-side.
Although he will not comment on the Bogdanoff paper, Mr. Majid said that the French version of his report on Grichka's thesis was "an unauthorized translation partially invented by the Bogdanovs.
They have the right to have their work recognized with a diploma, which is nothing much these days. The referee's report concluded: The mathematicians include Damien Calaque, and their comments can be found on another forum. The rumor appears to have begun with an email from the physicist Max Niedermaier to the physicist Ted Newman, and it spread like wildfire.
MATHEMATICAL CENTER OF RIEMANNIAN COSMOLOGY M.C.R.C. The standard "big-bang theory" sets the origin of the Universe at an infinitesimal limit called the Planck scale (10 power - 33 cm).
On 29 th of OctoberBourgogne University issued a text about Igor & Grichka Bogdanoff thesis in mathematics and theoretical physics. If you give me a private email (you can contact me at [email protected]) I can send you the copies of the thesis reports: you will see that the Honorable mention is present on Grichka's but not on mine.
This is a fact and one cannot deny it. In Octobera journalist from Ciel et Espace interviewed Shahn Majid of Queen Mary, University of London about his report on Grichka Bogdanov's thesis. Majid said that the French version of his report on Grichka's thesis was "an unauthorized translation partially invented by the Bogdanovs.".
The report spends much longer — 15 pages — dissecting Igor Bogdanov’s physics thesis. It concludes: “Unfortunately, even a rapid reading evokes strong suspicions about the scientific contribution and about the quality of presentation of this work; and a deeper analysis only confirms these suspicions.
Bogdanov Thesis Reports Posted on June 11, by woit From one of the comments here I see that the Bogdanovs have put the reports on their theses on the CERN document server.Bogdanov thesis reports